Pittsburgh’s food scene is no joke—especially when it comes to Italian cuisine. From old-school red sauce joints to modern trattorias, the Steel City serves up some seriously delicious pasta, pizza, and more.
Whether you’re craving a cozy date night spot or a family-friendly feast, Pittsburgh’s best Italian restaurants have got you covered.
Ready to dig in? We’ve scoured the city to bring you the top Italian eateries that’ll make your taste buds sing.
Think handmade gnocchi, wood-fired pies, and tiramisu so good you’ll want to order two. Let’s dive into the must-visit Italian spots in Pittsburgh—trust us, your stomach will thank you later.
1. Alla Famiglia – A High-End Italian Feast
If you’re looking for authentic Italian food in Pittsburgh with a side of elegance, Alla Famiglia is the move.
Nestled in Allentown, this spot is all about hearty, family-style dishes that’ll make you feel like you’re dining in Nonna’s kitchen—just fancier.
Their hand-rolled meatballs are legendary, and the veal parmigiana? Absolute perfection. Vegans aren’t left out either—their roasted vegetable risotto is creamy, dreamy, and totally plant-based.
The vibe here is upscale but welcoming, making it ideal for celebrations or when you just wanna treat yourself
2. DiAnoia’s Eatery – The Ultimate Pasta Paradise
DiAnoia’s Eatery in the Strip District is one of the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh, hands down. Their freshly made pasta is the star—think pillowy gnocchi, silky pappardelle, and rigatoni so good you’ll debate ordering a second plate.
Don’t skip their arancini—crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside, and downright addictive. They also have killer vegan options, like their eggplant caponata, which packs a flavor punch.
Plus, the bakery next door means you can grab a cannoli for the road.
3. Piccolo Forno – Cozy & Authentic
Lawrenceville’s Piccolo Forno brings rustic Italian charm to Pittsburgh. This place is small but mighty, serving up wood-fired pizzas and house-made pastas that’ll transport you straight to Italy.
Their butternut squash ravioli is a fan favorite, and the Margherita pizza? Simple, fresh, and oh-so-good. The vibe is casual but chic—perfect for a low-key dinner with friends.
4. Dish Osteria – A Hidden Gem
Tucked away in South Side, Dish Osteria is a sleek, intimate spot with a menu that changes seasonally. Their handmade pastas and slow-cooked sauces are next-level, and the grilled octopus (if you’re into seafood) is a must-try.
The ambiance is moody and romantic, making it a top pick for date night.
5. Pizzeria Davide – Pizza Like No Other
If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Pittsburgh, Pizzeria Davide in Shadyside is where it’s at. Their Neapolitan-style pies have that perfect charred crust and fresh toppings.
The truffle mushroom pizza is a game-changer, and they’ve got plenty of vegan-friendly options too.
6. Senti – Modern Italian with a Twist
Senti in Lawrenceville blends traditional Italian flavors with modern flair. Their black truffle pasta is rich and indulgent, while the roasted cauliflower steak keeps things light and flavorful.
Great for groups—order a bunch of dishes and share!
7. Garbarino’s – Old-School Vibes
A Pittsburgh Italian classic, Garbarino’s in East Liberty serves up hearty, no-frills dishes that hit the spot. The lasagna is a crowd-pleaser, and the garlic knots? You’ll want a whole basket.
8. Il Tetto – Rooftop Italian Dining
For Italian with a view, head to Il Tetto downtown. Their aperitivo hour (sans alcohol) is a vibe, and the burrata salad is creamy heaven
9. Spork – Creative Italian-American Eats
Spork in Garfield puts a fun spin on Italian-American favorites. Their Sunday gravy is legendary, and the vegan meatball sub is shockingly good.
10. Legume – Farm-to-Table Italian
Legume in Oakland focuses on seasonal, locally sourced Italian dishes. The house-made pappardelle is a must, and their roasted veggie plates are fresh and flavorful.
11. Pasta Too – Casual & Delicious
A hidden gem in Bethel Park, Pasta Too serves up homestyle Italian without the fuss. The eggplant rollatini is a standout.
12. Cafe Milano – A Taste of Italy in Bloomfield
Cafe Milano is a cozy, no-frills spot with hearty portions. The penne alla vodka (minus the vodka) is creamy and delicious.
13. Badamo’s – Sandwich Heaven
If you love Italian subs, Badamo’s in the North Side is a must. The caprese sandwich is fresh and satisfying.
14. Gio’s Trattoria – Family-Owned Goodness
Gio’s in Mt. Lebanon is all about warm hospitality and classic dishes. Their chicken piccata is lemony perfection.
15. Bella Notte – Strip District Staple
A longtime favorite, Bella Notte serves hearty Italian comfort food. The stuffed shells are a must-order.
16. Senti Restaurant – Modern Italian with a Creative Twist
Senti is where traditional Italian meets modern flair. Their black truffle gnocchi is so good it should be illegal, and their risottos? Creamy, dreamy heaven.
The space is sleek but inviting, making it perfect for a date night or a classy dinner out. And if you’re vegan? Their seasonal veggie dishes will blow your mind.
Bonus: More Amazing Italian Spots
- Pizzeria Volanti (Homemade pasta & pizza)
- La Tavola Italiana (Old-school charm)
- Fig & Ash (Modern Italian-American)
Final Thoughts: Your Next Italian Feast Awaits!
Pittsburgh’s Italian food scene is packed with flavor, tradition, and innovation. Whether you’re craving wood-fired pizza, handmade pasta, or vegan-friendly dishes, there’s something for everyone.
Which spot will you try first? Grab a fork and start exploring—your next unforgettable Italian meal is just around the corner!