Nashville might be famous for hot chicken and honky-tonks, but let’s not sleep on its killer Italian food scene. From cozy mom-and-pop joints to upscale trattorias, the city’s got enough pasta, pizza, and risotto to make even Nonna proud.
Whether you’re craving a hearty bowl of spaghetti or a wood-fired Margherita pizza, Music City delivers big time.
Ready to dive into the best Italian restaurants in Nashville? We’re talking handmade pastas, sauces simmered for hours, and desserts that’ll have you saying “just one more bite.”
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this list is your golden ticket to Nashville’s top Italian eats. Let’s dig in!
1. Moto Cucina + Enoteca
If you want authentic Italian with a modern twist, Moto Cucina + Enoteca is where it’s at. Located in the Gulch, this spot nails the balance between rustic charm and sleek sophistication.
Their hand-rolled gnocchi? Absolute perfection—light as a cloud and drenched in rich, savory sauce.
The menu changes with the seasons, so you’ll always find something fresh. Pro tip: Don’t skip the wood-grilled octopus—it’s a game-changer.
The vibe here is casual yet chic, making it perfect for date night or a fancy dinner with friends.
2. City House
Southern meets Italian at City House, one of Nashville’s most beloved spots. Chef Tandy Wilson’s James Beard Award-winning skills shine in dishes like belly ham pizza with sunny-side-up eggs—trust us, it’s a must-try.
The house-made pastas are next-level, especially the cavatelli with lamb sausage. The vibe? Warm, welcoming, and just a little bit hipster. Whether you’re sitting at the chef’s counter or the cozy patio, you’re in for a treat.
3. Penne Pazze
Tucked away in Germantown, Penne Pazze feels like a little slice of Italy. The homemade pasta is the star here—think silky pappardelle and al dente rigatoni in sauces that hug every bite.
Their vegan-friendly options are just as impressive, like the roasted eggplant marinara. And the tiramisu? Best in town. If you want authentic Italian without the fuss, this is your spot.
4. Coco’s Italian Market
Part restaurant, part gourmet market, Coco’s is Nashville’s go-to for Italian comfort food. Their Sunday gravy (a meaty, slow-cooked red sauce) is legendary, and the meatball sub? Pure happiness on a roll.
The vibe is laid-back and family-friendly, with shelves stocked with imported Italian goods. Grab a seat at the communal table and dig into hearty, no-frills Italian classics.
5. Amerigo Italian Restaurant
A Nashville staple since 1987, Amerigo brings old-school Italian charm to the table. Their spinach and ricotta ravioli is a fan favorite, and the eggplant parmigiana is crispy, cheesy perfection.
The warm bread and herbed olive oil alone are worth the visit. Whether you’re here for a weeknight dinner or a special occasion, Amerigo never disappoints.
6. Pastaria
From James Beard-winning chef Tony Mantuano, Pastaria is all about simple, fresh, and downright delicious Italian. The cacio e pepe is a must—creamy, peppery, and oh-so-satisfying.
Their wood-fired pizzas are crispy and loaded with top-notch toppings. The vibe is bright, modern, and super welcoming—great for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner.
7. Nicoletto’s Pasta Co.
If you’re all about build-your-own pasta bowls, Nicoletto’s is your dream come true. Choose your pasta, sauce, and toppings for a custom Italian masterpiece. The spicy diavolo sauce packs a punch, while the creamy Alfredo is pure comfort.
The fast-casual setup makes it perfect for a quick yet high-quality Italian fix. Plus, the garlic knots? Addictive.
8. Porta Via
This hidden gem in Green Hills serves up homestyle Italian with a gourmet touch. The chicken piccata is lemony, buttery, and downright heavenly.
Their vegan pasta options are just as stellar, proving that Italian food is for everyone. The cozy, intimate setting makes it a great spot for a low-key dinner.
9. Rolf and Daughters
Modern Italian with a creative edge—that’s Rolf and Daughters in a nutshell. Their garganelli verde (green pasta with pork ragù) is mind-blowing.
The industrial-chic space is cool without being pretentious, and the seasonal small plates keep things exciting. A must-visit for foodies who love bold flavors
10. Lockeland Table
While not strictly Italian, Lockeland Table’s wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas earn it a spot on this list. The community-style dining makes it feel like a big Italian family dinner.
The mushroom and truffle pizza is a showstopper, and the pappardelle bolognese is pure comfort.
11. 312 Pizza Company
Chicago-style deep dish in Nashville? Yes, please! 312 Pizza Company serves up thick, cheesy, saucy pies that’ll transport you to the Windy City.
The spinach and garlic white pizza is a sleeper hit, and the crispy thin crust holds its own too. Great for group feasts.
12. Five Points Pizza
NYC-style slices done right. Five Points Pizza nails the thin, foldable crust with just the right chew. The pepperoni with hot honey is a flavor explosion.
Grab a slice to-go or sit down for a full pie—either way, you’re winning.
13. Bella Napoli
This authentic Neapolitan pizzeria uses imported Italian flour and San Marzano tomatoes for the real deal. The Margherita pizza is simplicity at its finest.
The gelato is the perfect sweet finish. Bellissimo!
14. Maggiano’s Little Italy
A chain, but a dang good one. Maggiano’s serves huge portions of classic Italian-American dishes. The rigatoni with vodka sauce is creamy, tangy, and totally craveable.
Great for big groups or family dinners where everyone leaves stuffed.
15. Josephine
Upscale yet unpretentious, Josephine’s seasonal Italian-inspired dishes are a work of art. The ricotta gnudi melts in your mouth, and the roasted chicken with polenta is pure comfort.
Perfect for a date night or celebratory dinner.
16. Luogo – A Fresh Take on Italian Fare
Luogo brings a modern, seasonal twist to Italian cuisine in Nashville. Their roasted cauliflower with capers and raisins is a surprising standout, and their rigatoni alla vodka (hold the alcohol, of course) is pure comfort.
The space is bright and airy, making it a great spot for brunch or a leisurely dinner. Don’t leave without trying their affogato—espresso poured over vanilla gelato. Yes, it’s as amazing as it sounds.
Bonus: More Must-Try Italian Spots
- Lou Nashville – Handmade pastas and killer cocktails.
- Folk – Italian-leaning seasonal dishes in a cozy space.
- Tavola – Roman-style pizzas and fresh antipasti.
Final Thoughts: Mangia!
Nashville’s Italian food scene is packed with flavor, passion, and plenty of carbs. Whether you’re in the mood for a quick slice or a multi-course feast, this list has you covered.
So what are you waiting for? Pick a spot, grab a fork, and dig into the best Italian food Nashville has to offer. Your taste buds will thank you.
Which one are you trying first? Let us know in the comments!