San Diego is a food lover’s paradise, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, this sunny SoCal city doesn’t disappoint.
From cozy trattorias to upscale ristorantes, San Diego’s Italian food scene is packed with flavor, tradition, and a whole lot of charm.
Whether you’re craving handmade pasta, wood-fired pizza, or creamy tiramisu, there’s a spot here that’ll make you say “Mamma mia!”
Ready to dive into the best Italian restaurants in San Diego? We’ve scoured the city to bring you the crème de la crème—places that’ll make your taste buds sing.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these spots are worth every bite. So loosen that belt, grab a fork, and let’s dig in!
1. Monello – Little Italy’s Hidden Gem
Tucked away in the heart of Little Italy, Monello is where modern flair meets old-school Italian comfort. The vibe? Intimate, stylish, and just a little bit fancy without being stuffy.
Their house-made pastas are the real stars—think pillowy gnocchi and silky tagliatelle that melt in your mouth.
For something truly special, try their “Secret Ravioli”—a rotating stuffed pasta that changes daily.
And if you’re a cheese lover, don’t skip their burrata bar, where fresh mozzarella gets the royal treatment. Whether you’re on a date night or just treating yourself, Monello delivers big flavors in every bite.
2. Civico 1845 – A Taste of Southern Italy
If you’re craving authentic Southern Italian flavors, Civico 1845 is your go-to. This Little Italy hotspot brings Calabrian heat and Sicilian sweetness to the table, with dishes that feel like nonna’s cooking (if nonna was a Michelin-trained chef).
Their eggplant parmigiana is legendary—crispy on the outside, tender inside, and smothered in just the right amount of marinara.
And for pasta lovers, the paccheri alla vodka is a creamy, dreamy must-try. Plus, they’ve got plenty of vegan options, so everyone leaves happy.
3. Bencotto – Handmade Pasta Heaven
At Bencotto, pasta isn’t just food—it’s an art form. This stylish Little Italy eatery lets you customize your pasta—pick the shape, sauce, and add-ins for a meal that’s 100% you.
Their squid ink linguine is a showstopper, while the classic cacio e pepe keeps things simple but unforgettable.
The vibe here is warm and welcoming, perfect for family dinners or catching up with friends. And save room for dessert—their limoncello tiramisu is the perfect sweet ending.
4. Barbusa – Modern Sicilian Vibes
Barbusa brings a fresh, trendy twist to Sicilian classics. Think bold flavors, vibrant dishes, and a lively atmosphere that’ll make you feel like you’re dining in Palermo.
Their arancini (stuffed risotto balls) are crispy perfection, and the uni pasta (if you’re feeling adventurous) is rich, briny, and totally addictive.
With a mix of traditional and modern plates, Barbusa is a great spot for groups—everyone will find something to love.
5. Piatti – Coastal Italian Charm
Located in La Jolla, Piatti combines stunning ocean views with rustic Italian dishes.
Their wood-fired pizzas are crispy, cheesy, and downright irresistible, while the mushroom risotto is pure comfort in a bowl.
The outdoor patio is the place to be—especially at sunset. If you want great food with a side of killer views, Piatti nails it.
6. Buona Forchetta – San Diego’s Pizza Darling
With multiple locations across the city, Buona Forchetta has earned its rep as one of San Diego’s best Italian restaurants for pizza.
Their wood-fired pies have that perfect charred crust, and the Margherita DOC (made with imported ingredients) is as authentic as it gets.
The South Park location is especially charming, with a cozy patio that feels like a little slice of Naples.
7. Solunto Ristorante – Old-School Sicilian
For a taste of old-world Sicily, Solunto Ristorante in Little Italy is a must. This family-owned spot serves up classics like eggplant caponata and seafood linguine with serious authenticity.
The vibe is warm and nostalgic—like eating at your Italian grandma’s kitchen table.
8. Il Dandy – Trendy & Tasty
A newer addition to Barrio Logan, Il Dandy mixes Italian flavors with California freshness. Their cacio e pepe arancini is a game-changer, and the ricotta gnudi is light yet indulgent.
With artsy decor and a hip crowd, this spot is perfect for a fun night out.
9. Antica Trattoria – La Mesa’s Italian Secret
If you’re east of downtown, Antica Trattoria in La Mesa is worth the trip. Their wild boar pappardelle is rich and hearty, while the truffle risotto is pure luxury.
The cozy, romantic setting makes it ideal for date night.
10. Isola Pizza Bar – Neapolitan Perfection
Isola Pizza Bar in Little Italy nails Neapolitan-style pizza with a chewy, blistered crust and top-notch toppings. The Diavola (spicy salami) is a fan favorite.
Simple, delicious, and always satisfying.
11. Trattoria Don Pietro – Classic & Hearty
In the Gaslamp Quarter, Trattoria Don Pietro serves up generous portions of lasagna, osso buco, and other Italian comfort foods.
Great for when you want a hearty, no-fuss meal.
12. Osteria Romantica – A Little Slice of Rome
This La Jolla gem feels like a Roman trattoria, with dishes like amatriciana and carbonara that transport you straight to Italy.
Romantic, intimate, and oh-so-delicious.
13. Sicilia Bella – Family-Style Feasts
Sicilia Bella in Mira Mesa is all about big, shareable plates—perfect for groups. Their Sicilian-style pizza (thick crust, loaded with toppings) is a must.
Bring your appetite—portions here don’t play around.
14. Pomodoro Ristorante – Coastal Italian
Right near the beach, Pomodoro Ristorante offers fresh seafood pasta and a relaxed vibe. The linguine alle vongole (clams) is a standout.
Ideal for a post-beach lunch.
15. Filippi’s Pizza Grotto – A San Diego Staple
A local legend since 1950, Filippi’s is where you go for no-frills, old-school Italian. Their pepperoni pizza and spaghetti & meatballs are timeless.
Cash only, totally worth it.
16. The Godfather – Classic Italian-American Fare
The Godfather in Kearny Mesa serves up hearty, no-frills Italian-American dishes. Their chicken Parmigiana is massive, crispy, and smothered in marinara and melted cheese.
This place is all about big portions and bold flavors, perfect for when you’re craving comfort food. If you want no-nonsense Italian food in San Diego, The Godfather won’t disappoint
Bonus: Extra Italian Spots Worth Trying
- Mimmo’s Italian Village (charming, old-world feel)
- Vero Bistro (elegant, perfect for special occasions)
- The Venetian (homestyle dishes, generous portions)
Final Bite: Which Italian Spot Will You Try First?
San Diego’s Italian food scene is packed with winners, from cozy neighborhood joints to upscale dining gems.
Whether you’re in the mood for wood-fired pizza, handmade pasta, or classic comfort dishes, there’s a spot on this list that’ll hit the spot.
So what are you waiting for? Pick a place, grab a seat, and dig into the best Italian food San Diego has to offer. Your taste buds will thank you!
Which restaurant are you excited to try? Drop a comment or tag your foodie friends—because great meals are even better when shared.