Key West is a paradise for food lovers, where every bite feels like a celebration of tropical vibes and fresh seafood.
From cozy hideaways serving local favorites to spots offering innovative vegan dishes, the food scene here is as vibrant as its sunsets.
Whether you’re a seafood aficionado or someone who loves plant-based cuisine, this guide will take you on a journey to discover some of the island’s must-visit eateries.
So, are you ready to dig into the best of Key West? If yes, then here are 15+ best restaurants to visit in Key West to satisfy your taste buds!
1. Blue Heaven
Blue Heaven is the kind of place where you immediately feel at home.
Nestled under towering banyan trees and adorned with colorful decor, this spot has all the charm Key West is famous for.
It’s hard to resist their signature Key lime pie—complete with a meringue that reaches for the sky.
Seafood lovers will rave about their fresh fish sandwiches and buttery shrimp. But don’t worry if that’s not your vibe—there are tasty veggie burgers and other plant-based options for you to enjoy.
Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast (the banana pancakes are legendary!) or a laid-back dinner, Blue Heaven’s quirky ambiance makes it unforgettable.
2. Cafe Sole
Cafe Sole is a dreamy spot that combines Mediterranean-inspired flavors with the freshest ingredients from the Keys.
Their hogfish dish, topped with roasted shallots and creamy truffle sauce, feels like an indulgence you won’t forget.
If you’re vegetarian, you’ll be drawn to their roasted vegetable platter, brimming with seasonal goodness.
This tucked-away gem feels like a secret hideout, perfect for a relaxed dinner where every bite feels like a discovery.
3. The Cafe, A Mostly Vegetarian Place
As its name suggests, The Cafe is primarily vegetarian, offering a wide array of dishes for plant-based eaters.
Their menu includes tasty vegan options like tofu stir-fry, quinoa salads, and veggie tacos.
They also serve some non-vegetarian options, ensuring everyone finds something delicious to enjoy. The vibrant decor and friendly staff make it a welcoming spot for everyone.
4. Santiago’s Bodega
Santiago’s Bodega is an absolute must-visit for those who love shared plates.
This restaurant specializes in tapas-style dishes that include flavors from around the world.
From rich lamb patties to vegetarian croquettes, their menu caters to diverse palates.
The lively ambiance and colorful decor make it a fun place for groups. Be sure to try their fresh salads and artichoke hearts for a lighter bite!
5. Garbo’s Grill
Garbo’s Grill, a beloved food truck, offers fusion-style dishes bursting with flavor.
Their Korean BBQ tacos and shrimp burritos are crowd-pleasers, and they also have veggie-based options for non-meat eaters.
Known for its friendly vibe and beachy atmosphere, this spot is perfect for a quick yet fulfilling meal on the go. The flavors and quality make it clear why it’s one of Key West’s favorite spots.
6. Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar
Located away from the busy streets, Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar is a hidden gem in Key West.
They focus on locally sourced ingredients and serve up delightful dishes like fresh snapper and cauliflower steak, making it ideal for both vegans and seafood lovers.
The atmosphere is relaxed yet upscale, with outdoor seating that offers beautiful waterfront views.
7. El Siboney
El Siboney is a go-to for authentic Cuban cuisine in a casual setting.
Known for its flavorful black beans, plantains, and roasted chicken, it’s a comforting spot that captures the essence of Cuban flavors.
Vegetarians can indulge in rice and bean dishes or yuca with mojo sauce.
El Siboney is where locals go for a satisfying and affordable meal.
8. Fisherman’s Cafe
Located near the harbor, Fisherman’s Cafe is all about fresh seafood and laid-back vibes.
Their shrimp tacos and fish sandwiches are crowd favorites, bursting with flavor and prepared with care.
Even non-seafood eaters will find plenty to love with their veggie-packed options.
Add in the scenic waterfront views, and you’ve got the recipe for a perfect Key West dining experience.
9. Moondog Cafe & Bakery
Moondog Cafe & Bakery offers a diverse menu that ranges from hearty breakfasts to inventive lunch options.
Their vegan Buddha bowls and plant-based sandwiches are popular choices, while meat lovers will find satisfying dishes like their famous fish tacos.
The cafe also serves fresh-baked goods, including some of the best cookies in town. With its cozy, artistic interior, it’s a favorite for brunch.
10. Banana Cafe
For those looking for French cuisine with a Key West twist, Banana Cafe is the place to be.
Known for its crepes, both sweet and savory, this charming cafe offers options like smoked salmon and veggie crepes.
They also serve vegetarian-friendly salads and light fare perfect for a midday meal.
Banana Cafe’s balcony seating provides a great spot to watch the bustling streets of Key West.
11. Eaton Street Seafood Market & Restaurant
Eaton Street Seafood Market is a seafood lover’s paradise with dishes made from fresh catches of the day.
Known for their stone crab claws, lobster rolls, and grilled fish, they serve simple yet flavorful meals that showcase the best of Key West’s seafood.
There are also veggie sides for those who want a lighter bite alongside their seafood. This market-turned-restaurant is a local favorite!
12. Seaside Cafe at the Mansion
Set within a historic mansion, Seaside Cafe offers a mix of Italian and island-inspired dishes.
Their famous lobster pizza is a must-try, and they also have flavorful salads for those looking for vegetarian options.
The beachfront setting adds to the experience, making it an excellent spot for a sunset meal.
The elegant surroundings give it a unique charm that combines fine dining with a relaxed beach vibe.
13. Southernmost Beach Cafe
The Southernmost Beach Cafe offers a relaxed dining experience right by the ocean.
Their menu features a mix of seafood, American, and Caribbean dishes, with options like grilled mahi-mahi and veggie wraps.
The beachside seating allows you to enjoy the waves while you dine, making it a perfect spot for both lunch and dinner.
They also offer fresh tropical fruit plates, a great choice for a refreshing bite.
14. Date & Thyme Organic Cafe and Market
Date & Thyme is the ideal choice for those looking for organic and health-focused meals.
This cafe and market offers salads, wraps, and smoothies that are perfect for a light, nourishing meal.
With gluten-free and vegan options, it caters to a health-conscious crowd.
The laid-back vibe and outdoor seating make it a relaxing spot to recharge.
15. Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is a creative seafood restaurant with a unique twist.
Their menu offers everything from spiced shrimp to seared scallops, with vegetarian-friendly sides like roasted vegetables.
The eclectic decor and cozy atmosphere make it perfect for a relaxed evening meal.
This spot is known for its inventive flavors and welcoming ambiance, making it a great choice for foodies.
16. Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe
Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe is an Italian-inspired eatery with a focus on homemade pasta and fresh ingredients.
While they offer classic Italian meat dishes, there are also vegetarian pasta options, like their famous tomato basil spaghetti.
This cozy restaurant has outdoor seating under charming twinkling lights, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere.
Conclusion
Key West’s dining scene is a treasure trove of flavors, with options for every palate.
Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, creative vegetarian dishes, or indulgent desserts, this island has it all.
What is your favorite spot out of all? Let me know in the comments down below.