Brooklyn’s food scene is next-level, and when it comes to Italian cuisine, this borough doesn’t play around.
From old-school red-sauce joints to modern trattorias slinging handmade pasta, there’s something for every carb-loving soul.
Whether you’re craving a cozy date-night spot or a family-style feast, Brooklyn’s best Italian restaurants deliver big flavors, warm hospitality, and that unbeatable nonna’s kitchen vibe.
Ready to dive into Brooklyn’s top Italian eats? We’ve scoured the borough to bring you the absolute best spots—hidden gems, neighborhood staples, and trendy newcomers that’ll make you wanna cancel all other dinner plans. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you.
1. Lilia – Williamsburg’s Crown Jewel
If there’s one Italian restaurant in Brooklyn that’s always buzzing, it’s Lilia. Chef Missy Robbins’ Michelin-starred hotspot turns simple pasta into pure magic. The agnolotti with saffron and honey? Life-changing. The wood-fired seafood? Unreal.
The space is sleek yet warm, with an open kitchen that lets you watch the chefs work their magic.
Reservations are tougher than a last-minute subway seat, but snagging a table is 100% worth it. Pro tip: Try their sheep’s milk cheese-filled focaccia—it’s the stuff dreams are made of.
2. Frankies 457 Spuntino – A Carroll Garden Classic
Frankies 457 Spuntino is the kind of place that feels like home—if your home had insanely good homemade cavatelli and a backyard garden.
This Carroll Gardens staple has been serving up rustic Italian-American dishes since 2004, and it’s still a neighborhood favorite.
Their Sunday gravy (a slow-cooked meaty red sauce) is legendary, and the roasted beet salad with pistachios is a must-try. The vibe? Cozy, unpretentious, and perfect for a long, lazy meal with friends.
3. Olmsted – Italian-Inspired with a Brooklyn Twist
Olmsted isn’t your traditional red-sauce joint, but its Italian-inspired dishes are some of the most creative in Brooklyn.
The ricotta gnocchi with morel mushrooms melts in your mouth, and their seasonal veggie dishes (like the carrot crepe) are a veggie lover’s dream.
The backyard garden adds major charm, making this Prospect Heights spot ideal for a romantic dinner or a chill weekend brunch.
4. Barano – Southern Italian Comfort in Williamsburg
Craving hearty, Southern Italian flavors? Barano in Williamsburg brings the heat with wood-fired pizzas, handmade pastas, and a killer Sunday supper menu. Their rigatoni alla vodka is creamy perfection, and the lobster spaghetti? Chef’s kiss.
The rustic-chic decor and friendly service make it a great pick for groups. Plus, their happy hour deals are a steal.
5. Fausto – A Cozy Clinton Hill Gem
Fausto is where you go when you want elevated Italian without the fuss. The garlicky bucatini is a fan favorite, and their grilled octopus is tender, smoky, and downright addictive.
The wine list is stellar (though we won’t dive into that here), and the intimate setting makes it perfect for date night.
6. Rucola – Boerum Hill’s Rustic Charmer
Rucola nails the farm-to-table Italian vibe with fresh, seasonal dishes that change daily. Their pappardelle with wild boar ragu is rich and comforting, while the roasted chicken with salsa verde is simple but flawless.
The candlelit dining room feels straight out of a European bistro—total romance material.
7. Marco’s – Dyker Heights’ Hidden Red-Sauce Star
For old-school Italian-American vibes, Marco’s in Dyker Heights is the move. Think massive portions, garlicky bread, and classics like chicken parm that’ll have you unbuttoning your jeans.
It’s a no-frills spot with big flavors—perfect for family dinners or carb-loading before a night out.
8. Al Di Là Trattoria – Park Slope’s Venetian Treasure
Al Di Là Trattoria has been a Park Slope institution since 1998, and for good reason. Their silk handkerchief pasta with sage butter is legendary, and the braised rabbit polenta? Absolute fire.
The wait can be long (no reservations), but the food is worth every minute.
9. Ops – Bushwick’s Pizza & Pasta Paradise
Ops is where sourdough pizza meets handmade pasta, and the result is delicious chaos. Their mushroom pie with truffle oil is a must, and the cacio e pepe is as good as Rome’s.
The natural wine bar vibe (though we’re not focusing on that) makes it a hip hangout.
10. Il Porto – Bensonhurst’s Old-School Legend
Il Porto has been serving Brooklyn’s best veal chop since the ‘70s. The eggplant rollatini and linguine with white clam sauce are classics done right.
It’s a throwback spot with red-checkered tablecloths and big flavors.
11. LaRina Pastificio & Vino – Fort Greene’s Pasta Haven
LaRina is all about fresh, handmade pasta in a chic setting. The lamb ragu pappardelle is rich and hearty, while the burrata with peaches (seasonal) is a refreshing starter.
Great for a classy-but-casual night out.
12. Bamonte’s – Williamsburg’s Historic Red-Sauce Joint
Open since 1900, Bamonte’s is a true Brooklyn classic. The spaghetti with meatballs is iconic, and the pepper steak is pure nostalgia.
Dark wood, white tablecloths, and old-school charm make this a must-visit.
13. Don Angie – Modern Italian with a Twist
Don Angie in Williamsburg reinvents Italian-American favorites. Their lasagna for two (scrolled like a cinnamon roll) is viral for a reason—it’s unreal.
Upscale but fun, with bold flavors and Insta-worthy plating.
14. Gersi – Authentic Tuscan in Downtown BK
Gersi brings Florence to Brooklyn with dishes like pici pasta (thick, hand-rolled noodles) and bistecca alla Fiorentina (though we’re keeping it non-alcohol focused).
Elegant but not stuffy—great for a special occasion.
15. Lucali – The Pizza Pilgrimage
No Brooklyn Italian food list is complete without Lucali. This candlelit Carroll Gardens spot serves the best thin-crust pie in NYC. The calzone? Mind-blowing.
Be prepared to wait—it’s cash-only and BYOB (though we’re not diving into that).
16. F&F Pizzeria – No-Frills, All Flavor
When it comes to Brooklyn’s best pizza, F&F Pizzeria in Carroll Gardens is a heavyweight champ.
Their wood-fired pies are crispy, chewy, and topped with high-quality ingredients that sing with flavor. The white pizza with garlic and mozzarella? Chef’s kiss.
Don’t expect fancy décor—this place is all about the food. And trust us, that’s more than enough. If you’re hunting for top Italian pizzerias in Brooklyn, F&F should be at the top of your list.
Bonus: More Must-Try Spots
- Scarpetta (Modern Italian luxury)
- L’Artusi (Sleek, pasta-focused perfection)
- Bricolage (Vietnamese-Italian fusion—wild but works)
Final Bite: Which Italian Spot Will You Try First?
Brooklyn’s Italian restaurant scene is packed with winners, whether you want old-school charm, modern twists, or unbeatable pasta. From Lilia’s Michelin-starred dishes to Lucali’s legendary pizza, there’s no wrong choice.
So, what’s your move? Pick a spot, grab a seat, and get ready for a flavor explosion. Your perfect Italian meal in Brooklyn is waiting.